top of page

What Canada and Europe Really Need From Each Other

Lynn Lai
4 days ago
8 min read

Cover image by Zachary Quek.

Information within this article is taken to be accurate as of 18 October 2026.


Canada may become the European Union’s first “associate member”, a status that they will be defining together in the weeks to come. Ursula von der Leyen, the president of the European Commission, floated “associate membership” on 16 September, and Canada Prime Minister Mark Carney welcomed it the next day. The leaders are expected to start working out what it means when they meet for the 21st Canada-EU Summit in Montreal on 29-30 October.


Donald Trump announced sweeping tariffs on Liberation Day in April 2025, and America’s friends have spent the last 18 months learning to live with a partner that can and will rewrite rules overnight. For Canada, who has long regarded the US as its closest ally, the road ahead seems rocky.


An infographic on Canada’s Export Partners. Image credit: Visual Capitalist
An infographic on Canada’s Export Partners. Image credit: Visual Capitalist

Canada and the European Union (EU) are natural allies. As part of the Commonwealth, Canada fought alongside the Allies in both world wars, and stood with Europe on defence since the Cold War through the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, which 23 EU member states also belong to. In February 2026, Canada became the first non-European country to join Security Action for Europe (SAFE), the EU’s €150 billion defence loan scheme. The deal lets Canadian firms supply up to 80% of any project, against 35% for non-participants. 


Their economic ties are newer but a good foundation. In 2016 they signed the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA). It scrapped duties on 99% of tariff lines, and trade in goods and services reached €130 billion in 2025, up 80% from 2016. However, 10 of the 27 member states, including France, Italy, Poland, Belgium and Ireland have not ratified it.


The urgency for stronger ties probably came in August 2026, when trade talks between Canada and the US collapsed after Carney pulled his negotiators out, and Trump even renamed Lake Ontario, which borders both countries, “Lake America”. The US then slapped a 50% tariff on US$27.6 billion of Canadian goods, and Canada hit back dollar for dollar on American steel, dairy and appliances. 


Trump's Lake America. Image credit: CNN
Trump's Lake America. Image credit: CNN

What Each Side Wants


Canada and Europe have been reminded that trade ties can be weaponised. Carney said as much at the World Economic Forum in Davos in January, warning that integration can become “the source of your subordination”.


In 2025, Canadian goods exports to the US fell 5.8%, while those to the EU rose 23.4%, to CA$42.8 billion. Washington has since added bans on some Canadian dairy, alcohol and other goods on top of its tariffs. Even so, exports to the US dwarfs the exports to the EU by about 13 times. While a growing European market for Canadian goods can soften the blow US tariffs may have, it cannot replace the American market anytime soon. Canada needs to create alternatives in strategically important sectors, so that a dispute with Washington does not leave it without options. 


Europe’s problem is the reverse, as it imports most critical resources, such as energy and rare earths, from beyond the EU. Since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, Russia’s share of the EU’s pipeline gas imports fell from about 40% in 2021 to about 6% in 2025, and the US filled much of this gap. America supplied 26% of all EU gas imports and almost 58% of its liquefied natural gas last year, which is worrying that Europe has swapped dependence on Moscow to dependence on Washington that threatens it with tariffs. Replacing one dominant supplier with another does not necessarily make a country more secure. Europe needs a broader range of suppliers, alongside the infrastructure and domestic capacity to reduce its exposure to any one of them.


Rare earths are an even bigger headache. The EU gets all its heavy rare earths, 85% of its light rare earths and 98% of its rare-earth magnets from China, and these metals go into everything from electric-car motors to fighter jets. When Beijing restricted rare-earth exports on 4 April 2025 in response to Liberation Day, rare earth prices rose as much as sixfold and some car plants halted production. China went further by barring rare-earth exports to 14 European companies in July 2026, among them the German arms maker Rheinmetall, with a second wave of controls is expected on 10 November. 


To address this dependency, the EU announced the Critical Raw Materials Act, which commits it to processing 40% of the strategic raw materials it uses by 2030, and to drawing no more than 65% of any of them from a single foreign country. Peter Handley, a former European Commission official who negotiated the 2021 EU-Canada raw materials partnership, is pessimistic about Europe to reaching the 40% goal. Building processing capacity requires substantial investment, reliable energy supplies and years of planning. As it stands, Europe cannot simply walk away from China. 


Meeting in the Middle


Canada's mineral wealth will not solve Europe's problem on its own, for Canada mines far more than it refines. It produces about 2% of global output of key battery minerals, sends much of its raw concentrate abroad for refining, often to China, and only has one active copper smelter. China controls about 70% of global refining for 19 of the 20 most critical minerals. 


Handley thinks this middle stage of the supply chain is where the two could work together. In his view, Canada's cheap, low-carbon electricity and its existing aluminium, nickel, copper, cobalt and zinc processing would pair well with Europe's industrial demand and separation know-how. A Canadian company, Neo Performance Materials, already runs the only major rare-earth magnet plant operating in the EU in Estonia. Canada has the raw materials and some of the processing capacity, while Europe has industrial demand and technical expertise. Should they work together, they can create supply chains that are less dependent on China, which would be critical if Europe is serious about reviving their automobile industry. 


Building more of that capacity will take years and a lot of money. According to the Royal Bank of Canada, Canada has put only 11% of its mining capital into critical minerals over the past 25 years, and permits for new projects can take more than five years. Energy will be slower still, since nearly all of Canada's piped gas exports still go to the US, and the Canada-EU Summit’s agenda includes only a feasibility study on shipping gas to Europe.


Then, there’s the problem of the Arctic, where Canada’s Yukon, Northwest Territories and Nunavut are, as well as European Arctic states of Denmark, Finland and Sweden. There is increasing global interest in the region, with Russia sending an oil-tanker convoy along a rarely used route deep in the Arctic, and Chinese shipping lines booking passage along Russia’s Arctic coast to cut the trip from China to Britain by about three weeks. Amidst all this, Washington has been scaling back its research there.


Canada and the EU have already promised to collaborate in the region. Their 2025 summit agreement said the Arctic "will remain an area of close collaboration to foster peace and security", but set up no specific project. So far, concrete cooperation has come through other channels. Canada and the EU both have, or will soon have, diplomatic offices in Nuuk, Greenland's capital, and Canada is one of eight countries linking their military satellites through NATO's HALO project. Von der Leyen's proposal would go further, with a joint Arctic "flagship project" that may see further details following the Montreal summit. 


Associate Member Status?


There is still a lot of confusion over what privileges Canada will enjoy with this new position in the EU. However, it has been made clear that it would not automatically confer full EU member privileges, such as a vote in the European Parliament, a seat on the Commission, EU citizenship or free movement for its peoples. Carney also insists that Canada is not trying to join the EU.


Fulfilling all these lofty goals will be challenging. Fabian Zuleeg of the European Policy Centre, a Brussels think tank, expects an ordinary association agreement and thinks the "associate member" label is misleading. Any such deal would need the backing of all 27 member states and the European Parliament, which is a tall order when ten EU member-states have yet to ratify CETA. The label may promise more than what the eventual agreement can deliver. However, the more important question is whether the agreement enables Canada and the EU to embark on new projects and partnerships that were difficult before. 


The Montreal Test


Ahead of the summit, a draft joint statement listed a digital trade deal, money from the European Investment Bank (the EU's lending arm) for Canadian mines and a study into shipping liquefied natural gas to Europe. Canada was also to open talks on joining Erasmus+, EU’s student exchange programme, and the two sides were to order 50 Canadian-made water bombers together to fight wildfires by 2030.


Lessons for Other Middle Powers


In the same Davos speech, Carney warned that middle powers must act together, because those not at the table end up on the menu. Canada's experiment carries lessons for any mid-sized trading economy that is dependent on one great power. The parts of its partnership with Europe that are actually evolving, such as minerals financing and defence contracts, are where each side supplies something the other needs.


Diversification will always be slow. Pipelines, refineries and ports are built over decades, and requires ongoing investment and resources from officeholders to see these efforts through. Middle powers want different things, so instead of forming one big alliance, they are more likely to team up on specific problems, such as critical minerals or defence, with whichever partners need the same thing. So most of the progress will still come from small, practical deals on defence, minerals and digital trade. 


What von der Leyen suggested through ‘associate membership’ may imply lofty ideals and the promise of stronger friendship over many areas, and it may never come true. However, the minerals and defence deals will, and they will do more to make Canada and Europe harder to bully. For middle powers, the lesson here is that dependence can be managed, even if it does take a long time. The more alternatives they build, the less leverage any single great power has over them. Time will tell if associate membership for Canada bears fruit.


Bibliography

  1. Agence France Presse. (2026, September 30). Canada, EU readying deals on minerals, water bombers in effort to draw closer. Canadian Affairs. https://www.canadianaffairs.news/2026/09/30/canada-eu-readying-deals-on-minerals-water-bombers-in-efforts-to-draw-closer/

  2. Batista Cabanas, L., & Heinz, E. (2026, September 29). What is an EU “associate member?” Why is Canada the first? euronews.com. Euronews. https://www.euronews.com/2026/09/29/what-is-an-eus-associate-member-why-is-canada-the-first

  3. Besch, S., Feldstein, S., Patrick, S., & Wanless, A. (2026, January 22). Carney’s remarkable message to middle powers. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. https://carnegieendowment.org/emissary/2026/01/carney-middle-powers-davos-speech

  4. Burdeau, C. (2026, September 15). Carney pursues “unique alliance” with EU as Canada pivots away from US. Courthouse News Service. https://www.courthousenews.com/carney-pursues-unique-alliance-with-eu-as-canada-pivots-away-from-us

  5. Can Yilmaz, M., & Evi Kiorri. (2026, September 30). What does it mean to be an “associate member” of the EU? euronews.com. Euronews. https://www.euronews.com/2026/09/30/what-does-it-mean-to-be-an-eu-associate-member-of-the-eu

  6. Canada Energy Regulator. (2026, May 27). Market Snapshot: Overview of 2025 Canada-U.S. Energy Trade. https://www.cer-rec.gc.ca/en/data-analysis/energy-markets/market-snapshots/2026/market-snapshot-overview-of-2025-canada-us-energy-trade.html

  7. Department of Finance Canada. (2026, August 25). List of products from the United States subject to counter-tariffs effective September 8, 2026. Government of Canada. https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2026/08/list-of-products-from-the-united-states-subject-to-counter-tariffs-effective-september-8-2026.html

  8. European Commission. (2025, June 23). Joint Statement following the European Union - Canada 2025 Summit: Enduring Partnership, Ambitious Agenda. https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/da/statement_25_1600

  9. European Council. (2026, March 2). Where does the EU’s gas come from? https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/infographics/where-does-the-eu-s-gas-come-from/

  10. Evi Kiorri. (2026, October 1). Can Canada be the EU’s answer to “unreliable” trade partners? euronews.com. Euronews. https://www.euronews.com/2026/10/01/can-canada-be-the-eus-answer-to-unreliable-trade-partners

  11. Global Affairs Canada. (2026, February 22). Agreement between the European Union and Canada concerning participation under the SAFE instrument. https://www.international.gc.ca/world-monde/international_relations-relations_internationales/eu-ue/agreement-accord.aspx?lang=eng

  12. Handley, P. (2026, August 5). On Critical Minerals, Canada and Europe Meet in the Midstream. Policy Magazine. https://www.policymagazine.ca/on-critical-minerals-canada-and-europe-meet-in-the-midstream/

  13. Jamasmie, C. (2026, February 27). Canada’s critical minerals push faces capital gap: RBC. The Northern Miner Group. Mining.Com. https://www.mining.com/canadas-critical-minerals-push-faces-capital-gap-rbc/

  14. Kasonta, A. (2026, October 17). China, Russia quietly moving toward a new arctic axis. Asia Times. https://asiatimes.com/2026/10/china-russia-quietly-moving-toward-a-new-arctic-axis/

  15. Kříž, V. (2026, March 3). European Union faces loss of key rare earth project. Oenergetice.Cz. https://oenergetice.cz/en/quick-news/european-union-faces-loss-of-key-rare-earth-project

  16. Maher, K. (2026, August 27). Trump signs executive order to change Lake Ontario to ‘Lake America’. CNN. https://www.cnn.com/2026/08/27/politics/trump-canada-lake-ontario-america

  17. Peltz, J. (2026, September 23). Canada’s top diplomat talks up its “middle powers strategy” at UN. AP News. https://apnews.com/article/un-general-assembly-canada-anand-3faa6bcdf1834ec9ed729312d3bf6e3f

  18. Rawnsley, J. (2026, September 17). Canada welcomes EU proposal to become “associate member.” BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwly7vkke4jxo

  19. Staalesen, A. (2026, August 10). In unprecedented Arctic operation, Russia sends convoy of oil tankers to 81.5°N. The Barents Observer. https://www.thebarentsobserver.com/news/in-unprecedented-arctic-operation-russia-sends-convoy-of-oil-tankers-to-815n/455488

  20. Szczepanski, M. (2025, November 24). China’s rare-earth export restrictions. European Parliament. https://eprs.europarl.europa.eu/sites/eprsweb/contents/publications/EPRS/2025/11/EPRS_ATA(2025)779220.html

  21. Taylor-Vaisey, N., & Blanchfield, M. (2026, August 23). Carney Bucks Trump as trade war escalates. Politico. Politico. https://www.politico.com/news/2026/08/22/carney-trump-trade-war-canada-01046743

  22. Yousif, N. (2026a, February 6). Canada and France to open Greenland Consulates after Trump demands. BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0r4lrly44xo

  23. Yousif, N. (2026b, September 29). US ban on Canadian alcohol and dairy comes into effect as trade war drags on. BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cm1j43y146d2o


Comments


bottom of page